The boxing community is buzzing with excitement—and skepticism—over the announcement of the rematch between Jose ‘Rayo’ Valenzuela and Isaac ‘Pitbull’ Cruz, which is set to feature on the undercard of David Benavidez versus David Morrell on January 25th in Las Vegas. While the prospect of any boxing rematch typically generates interest, the response this time around has been noticeably divided. The initial bout on August 3 showcased a dominant performance from Valenzuela, leaving many fans questioning whether a second encounter is warranted.
Valenzuela, who holds the WBA light welterweight title (standing at 14 wins, 2 losses with 9 knockouts), appeared to have outclassed Cruz, a former champion with a record of 26 wins, 3 losses, and 1 draw (18 knockouts). The fight concluded with Valenzuela winning decisively, indicated by the judges’ scorecards that read 116-112 (twice) and 115-113 in favor of Cruz. For many observers, this wide margin of victory raises red flags about Cruz’s readiness to compete at this level again. Would fans genuinely benefit from a rematch, or are they merely being offered a filler fight?
Despite the announcement, one can’t overlook the undercurrent of skepticism that permeates fan discussions surrounding this rematch. Many feel that the lopsided nature of their first outing rendered a second bout less compelling. If Cruz had displayed resilience or demonstrated improvement by defeating a reputable opponent since their last clash, fan enthusiasm might have flourished. However, his previous performance against Valenzuela left room for doubt, making it difficult to rally support for a sequel.
Moreover, the clearer picture of potential outcomes raises another layer of frustration. Fans seem eager to witness fights that lead to possibilities for more significant matchups or enthralling narratives. With Cruz appearing outmatched in their last faceoff, it feels more like a challenge for him to reclaim relevance rather than an epic battle of champions.
Conversely, the true highlight of the upcoming card promises to be the main event featuring Benavidez (the WBC interim super middleweight champion) against Morrell, who boasts an undefeated record of 11-0 (9 KOs). This fight has all the ingredients of a memorable showdown. Both fighters display tremendous skill, and their contrasting styles generate a sense of unpredictability. Morrell, noted for his punch power reminiscent of renowned fighters Adonis Stevenson and Artur Beterbiev, poses a serious threat to Benavidez, who struggled to absorb hits against Oleksandr Gvozdyk in his previous outing at 175 lbs.
Spectators are speculating about the risk level involved in this match, particularly whether Benavidez can withstand Morrell’s one-punch knockout power. If Morrell can capitalize on any momentary lapses in Benavidez’s defense, the outcome may be markedly different from the earlier clash between Valenzuela and Cruz.
Another layer of intrigue revolves around the winner of the Beterbiev vs. Bivol fight scheduled for October 12, with potential ramifications for the winner of Benavidez and Morrell. A future matchup involving these champions would elevate the stakes considerably. Still, the landscape could shift dramatically if either of the victors from these upcoming bouts chooses to vacate or enter a rematch.
As fans turn their attention to January 25th, opinions oscillate wildly. The Valenzuela vs. Cruz rematch has the specter of an anticlimax, while the headlining act bears the promise of fireworks—truly the diamond in the rough for an eagerly anticipated boxing event.