Trainer Stephen Edwards has made it clear that he believes Caleb Plant should feel insulted that it has taken Trevor McCumby 14 years to face a big-name opponent like Plant. Edwards argues that McCumby should have stepped up to face quality fighters much sooner. On the contrary, Edwards seems to forget that Plant himself has been shielded from top competition, with his only win in his last three fights coming against an aging Anthony Dirrell.
Despite Plant’s desire for a rematch with Canelo Alvarez, fighting an inexperienced fighter like McCumby seems to be the perfect opportunity for Plant to secure that second fight. This strategic matchmaking by promoters has allowed Plant to maintain his chances of winning the WBA interim title. However, it raises the question of whether Plant truly deserves another shot at Canelo, given his recent performances against elite competition.
Past Performance vs. Quality of Opponents
While it is true that Plant has faced better competition than McCumby, it is essential to note that Plant holds a 0-2 record against top fighters. His losses to Canelo Alvarez and David Benavidez raise doubts about his ability to compete at the highest level. Edwards may argue that Plant has fought better competition, but it is evident that simply facing top opponents is not enough if one cannot secure victories against them.
Trainer Stephen Edwards praises Plant for stepping up against better competition than McCumby, but he fails to acknowledge that Plant’s sole win in his last three fights came against an aging Anthony Dirrell. Dirrell, at 38 years old, was far from his prime when Plant faced him. Therefore, it is questionable to consider Dirrell as quality competition, casting doubt on Plant’s ability to consistently perform against top opponents.
While Trainer Stephen Edwards may believe that Caleb Plant should feel insulted by Trevor McCumby’s delayed step up in competition, a closer examination of Plant’s recent performances and opponents reveals a more nuanced story. Plant’s record against top fighters, coupled with strategic matchmaking, raises concerns about his readiness to compete at the highest level. As Plant continues his boxing career, it will be crucial for him to prove his capabilities against elite competition to silence any doubts about his true potential in the sport.